People who never throw with old clothes because “they might come back in style” often display these 5 traits

If you peeked into my closet, you’d find a few “vintage” items lurking in the back. I haven’t worn my old denim jacket or neon leggings in ages, yet I just can’t toss them. Why? A little voice insists, “They might come back in style!” 

If this sounds familiar, you’re not alone. Many of us hang onto fashion relics with that hopeful mantra. Interestingly, this quirky habit often reflects some deeper personality patterns. Today, we unpack five of these.

1. A sentimental streak 

I once found my mum’s sequined dress from the 80s buried in our attic. She hadn’t worn it in decades, but when I asked why she kept it, she just smiled. “It reminds me of my university days,” she said. 

That kind of sentimental streak is a hallmark of people who cling to old clothes. It’s not really about the garment – it’s about the memories woven into it. In other words, letting go of the outfit feels like letting go of a part of themselves. No wonder it’s so hard to drop that prom dress in the donation bin!

There’s actually science behind this nostalgia. As Jennifer Baumgartner, psychologist and author of You Are What You Wear, has explained:  “Shopping and spending behaviors often come from internal motivations such as emotions, experiences, and culture,”

If you have a sentimental soul, you probably treat certain outfits as priceless mementos. That “out-of-style” jacket isn’t clutter; it’s a story, a feeling, a reminder of who you were when you wore it. And people with this trait will happily make space in the closet for all those stories.

2. Optimism and foresight 

Have you noticed how trends tend to come full circle every few decades? (High-waisted jeans and scrunchies, I’m looking at you.) Some people don’t just notice this – they count on it. 

Rather than seeing change as a reason to purge, they see it as a chance for old favorites to shine again. That floral dress might be hopelessly out of vogue today, but just wait – in a few years, it could be the star of your wardrobe once more. 

This trait isn’t just about fashion; it hints at someone who takes the long view in life. They’re patient and forward-thinking. Why rush to get rid of something now if it could be valuable later? 

In psychology, being able to delay gratification (like waiting years to rock that item again) shows discipline and belief in future rewards. This optimistic outlook often extends beyond the closet. Such individuals might approach their goals and challenges the same way – trusting that today’s investments will pay off tomorrow. They have an eye on the horizon and a knack for spotting potential. When fashion “recycles” an old trend, they’re ready and smiling. 

After all, what’s old will always be new again if you wait long enough – and these future-focused folks are nothing if not patient. 

3. Thriftiness and resourcefulness 

“Why buy something twice?” That’s the kind of practical question a thrifty person might ask – and it’s another reason some of us hoard old clothes. 

People who keep outfits for a potential style renaissance often value resourcefulness. They hate waste, whether it’s money or materials. 

If you’ve ever held onto a coat thinking, “It’s still in good shape, it’ll save me money when it’s back in style,” you’re displaying this trait. Rather than tossing perfectly usable clothes (only to re-buy them later), these individuals prefer to “shop” their own closets when trends return. It’s a financially savvy move, and as a single mom, I can attest to the appeal of not having to shell out for the latest fad when I’ve got the original at home!

Interestingly, this trait has a side benefit: it’s eco-friendly. Fashion waste is a huge problem – around 92 million tonnes of textiles end up in landfills each year​. By hanging onto clothes and reusing them, these individuals reduce demand for new purchases and keep old garments out of the dump a little longer.

Whether motivated by saving money, the planet, or just the satisfaction of being prepared, the resourceful type wears their old-clothes habit like a badge of honor. They prove the adage “waste not, want not.” In their eyes, a closet full of “has-beens” isn’t clutter; it’s an archive of future possibilities. And when a trend does cycle back, their frugality pays off – literally.

4. Fear of regret (a cautious mindset) 

On the flip side of optimism is a less sunny reason for hoarding clothes: the fear of regret. Ever pull something out for donation, only to shove it back thinking, “What if I need this later?” If so, you understand this trait. 

Some people who never purge their closet often have a cautious, risk-averse streak. They’re deeply uncomfortable with the idea of missing out or realizing they made a mistake by throwing something away. 

Psychologically, this comes from a well-known bias: loss aversion. We tend to feel more pain from losing something than joy from gaining something of equal value. In practice, that means the possibility of later regretting a purge can loom larger than the definite relief of a clean closet today. Over time, those closets fill up with “what if” items. 

This cautious approach also often extends beyond wardrobes. These individuals often think twice (or thrice) before making big decisions in life. They like to hedge their bets and avoid irreversible moves. 

Change can be scary if it feels final. However, living in fear of future regret can become its own burden. It’s ironic – in trying to avoid the pain of loss, one might end up shouldering the weight of clutter and stagnation. 

Sound familiar? Recognizing this cautious mindset is the first step to balancing it with a bit of bravery – whether that means finally letting go of those bell-bottoms or taking another type of leap you’ve been putting off.

5. Preparedness and “just in case” planning 

Picture this: your friend invites you to a last-minute 90s-themed party. Everyone else is scrambling to find something to wear, but you stroll over to your closet and pull out a pristine Spice Girls-era jacket you’ve kept since high school. No stress, no shopping trip needed – you were prepared. 

Being ready for anything is another trait of folks who keep old clothes around. They have a just-in-case mindset not out of fear, but out of a love of preparedness. If Trait #4 was about anxiety of regret, Trait #5 is about the confidence of being ready for opportunities.

In life, some folks like to have an ace up their sleeve. The same goes for their wardrobe. That old suit might come in handy for a future job interview; that vintage gown could be perfect if gala fashions swing back around. 

This trait overlaps with resourcefulness, but it’s more about planning ahead than penny-pinching. These individuals get a sense of comfort knowing they have what they might need. It’s a bit like keeping an umbrella in your bag on a clear day – not because you expect rain, but because if it does rain, you’ll be glad you were forward-thinking.

Far from being impulsive, these folks tend to be planners. Holding onto old clothes is actually part of their strategic foresight: fashion is one of those cyclical things in life you can predict. They know that if they maintain what they have, they’ll save time and hassle when the wheel of style turns in their favor. There’s a sense of pride in being the one who can say, “Oh, I have just the thing for this!” Whether it’s lending a friend a retro outfit or effortlessly joining a revived trend, they’re ready.

Of course, this can tip into over-preparation (there’s only so much one can prepare for, after all). But generally, this trait means the person is forward-looking and strategic. They hate being caught off-guard. And truth be told, the world needs planners and Boy Scout-types who are always prepared. 

If you recognize this in yourself, you probably extend it beyond clothes – maybe you save useful files on your computer, keep detailed calendars, or stock up on supplies “just in case.” It’s all part of the same pattern. You’re not “hoarding”; you’re “anticipating”. And when opportunity (or a costume party) knocks, you answer with a smile and a perfectly pre-planned outfit.

Wrapping up

Take a moment to reflect: do any of these traits ring true for you? If you’ve been nodding along, your closet habits might be telling you something about your inner world. 

Perhaps you cherish memories and have a big heart, or you’re an optimist quietly betting on brighter days. Maybe you’re a whiz at making the most of what you have, or a careful soul who hates remorse. You could be the planner who’s ready for anything. 

In truth, many of us who hang onto old clothes are a mix of these traits – sentimental and strategic, hopeful and a tad hesitant to change.

Recognizing these patterns is helpful because it turns a quirky habit (like hoarding old fashions) into a chance for self-awareness. 

If your sentimental side is cluttering your life, you can practice letting go in small ways without losing the memories (maybe take a photo of that old concert tee and then donate it). 

If your cautious mind clings out of fear, you might challenge yourself to release one item and see how you feel – chances are you’ll feel lighter. 

And if you’re the eternal optimist holding ten pairs of “vintage” jeans, well, maybe keep a couple and consider passing the rest on to someone who can enjoy them now.

The thing is, none of these traits are “bad” – each has a strength. It’s all about balance. You can honor your past without living in it, save for the future without crowding out the present. 

So next time you hesitate at the closet with that “might come back in style” excuse, smile and ask yourself: What deeper trait is this reflecting in me? 

By understanding ourselves better, we can make choices that keep us growing, happy, and true to who we are – with a wardrobe that supports us (and maybe even sparks joy) every step of the way. Here’s to loving our quirks, learning from them, and wearing our personal growth as proudly as our favorite old jacket!

Total
0
Shares
Related Posts