Standards
Editorial Standards
Direct Message News is a curation and reporting site about the arguments in culture and politics. Most of what we publish is a daily board of issues, each pairing other outlets’ reporting with other people’s posts and videos that cut through. Some of what we publish is our own reporting. The publication is responsible for every word we put behind our name, in either mode.
1. Sourcing and linking
We prefer primary sources. For our own reporting and for any factual claim we make in our own voice, we try to link to the document that supports it: a vote tally, a filing, a budget line, a ruling, a transcript, a dataset, a recorded statement.
- Every factual claim should trace back to a source a reader can open.
- Links open the original, not a mirror. When the source is paywalled or geoblocked, we say so.
- Links are not proof on their own. A linked source is judged on relevance, proximity to the claim, date, and whether a second independent source is needed.
- Where we restate another outlet’s reporting, we name the outlet in the sentence and link to them, not to ourselves.
We send credit and traffic to the people who did the work.
2. Quoting posts and other writers
When we feature someone else’s post, three rules apply.
- Verbatim. We quote the author’s own words. We do not paraphrase and attribute. If a post is too long to publish in full, we cut cleanly with ellipses and keep the meaning intact.
- Linked to the original. Every featured post includes a link to where the author first posted it. If the original is deleted later, we note that on the feature.
- In context. We publish enough of the surrounding thread or piece that the quoted sentence cannot be fairly called ripped out of context. If a reader would need to see the next sentence to judge ours, we include the next sentence.
3. How selection works, and its limits
Which issues make the board and which posts cut through is decided against a public rubric. We try to be transparent about how it is applied.
- The methodology page sets out the public rubric we use for both.
- The daily board is assembled with software, including AI tools, and publishes without a pre-publication sign-off. Editors review it after it goes live and correct or remove entries that fail the test.
- Being on our allowlist of recurring communicators is not a standing invitation. Every post is judged on its own.
- Selection is not endorsement. Featuring a post means that post, on that issue, on that day, did the work. It does not mean we vouch for the author’s other posts, past or future.
- We will sometimes be wrong about what cut through. When we are, we expect readers to tell us, and we take the feedback on the record.
4. Independence from advertisers
Direct Message News is published by Brown Brothers Media. The business of selling advertising, sponsorship, and affiliate placements is kept separate from the business of deciding what to publish.
- No advertiser, sponsor, or affiliate partner is shown our editorial choices in advance.
- Paid content is labelled clearly so it is visually distinct from editorial coverage.
- A company that advertises with us gets no softer treatment and no harder treatment than one that does not.
- Our standards sit within Brown Brothers Media’s editorial framework, which applies across its publications.
If you believe an editorial decision was shaped by a commercial relationship, write to corrections@dmnews.com. We will investigate on the record.
5. Corrections
When a material factual error is confirmed, we correct the article promptly and append a dated correction note explaining what was wrong and what is now right. Smaller spelling, grammar, formatting, and broken-link repairs may be made silently.
- The correction note stays with the article. We do not quietly edit history.
- When a featured post or one of our notes on it turns out to be wrong, we say so plainly on the issue, and we say why it failed the test we hold ourselves to.
- For how to request a correction, see the corrections policy.
6. Use of AI tools
We use software, including AI tools, in our work. We are clear about what the tools do and what they do not do.
- Software, including AI tools, scans trending searches, news feeds and public platforms each day, shortlists the issues, and drafts the issue briefs and the one-line notes on why each voice cuts through.
- The daily issue board publishes automatically and is reviewed by editors after it goes live. Articles under a named byline are published by a person. The publication is responsible for every word either way.
- Featured posts are pulled directly from the platforms and quoted exactly as written.
- Tools are never used to fabricate quotations, invent sources, generate statistics, or present generated material as first-hand reporting.
- Where an article materially depends on an AI-assisted draft, we disclose that in the article.
- Any synthetic image, audio, or video is labelled when the use could change a reader’s understanding of what is real.
7. Conflicts of interest
- Writers disclose any financial interest, employment, or close personal relationship with a person, company, campaign, or agency they cover. Disclosures appear in the article.
- Writers do not accept payment, gifts, or travel from a subject of coverage.
- Direct Message News discloses when a parent company, sister publication, or investor is itself the subject of coverage.
- Editors and reviewers recuse themselves from stories where their own disclosures would compromise independence.
8. Removal requests from featured writers
If we have quoted or linked to a post of yours and you want to be removed, you can ask us to take you out of the feature. We will.
- Email corrections@dmnews.com from the account that owns the post, or from an address visibly connected to it.
- We remove the quote and the link from the feature, and we replace them with a short note that a quote was removed at the author’s request. We do not name you in the note if you do not want to be named.
- If the post was already part of a wider published story and removing it would distort the public record, we will discuss what to replace it with before we edit.
- We do not remove features because a subject of an article objects to how they are covered. The removal policy is for the authors we feature, not for the people our featured authors write about.
9. Scope, byline conventions, and responsibility
- Our focus is the stories culture and politics are arguing about: verdicts, elections, scandals, public health, technology and the media itself. Most are American or British; we cover others when people are arguing about them here.
- A named byline means the piece was written and published by that person.
- Direct Message News editors or the Direct Message News editors is our staff byline, used when the publication, rather than one named person, takes credit for a piece.
- The publication stands behind every article under either byline.
Questions about any of this: corrections@dmnews.com.