Russell Brand jailed for rape: what the jury actually had to decide
Brand's defenders call it a stitch-up and his critics call it overdue. The jury convicted on some counts and acquitted on others, so the verdict has to be read count by count.
The noise
- BRAND'S DEFENDERS An establishment stitch-up of a man who turned against it, with no forensic evidence.
- HIS CRITICS Proof that fame and a public conversion protected a predator for years.
Cuts through
Important detail re the Russell Brand verdict: The phrase "beyond reasonable doubt" is no longer used to instruct juries. Juries are now instructed in the language of "being sure," as in, "Are you sure that the defendant either knew she was not consenting or was reckless as to whether she did or did not consent?" The judge (Mr Justice Bennathan) gave the jury a written “route to verdict” with a series of questions for each count. These repeatedly asked “Are you sure…" These is the recommended Crown Court Compendium approach used in today's English and Welsh jury trials. Cc …
Why it cuts through Describes how juries are now asked to decide consent: whether they are sure he knew she was not consenting, or was reckless about it. That is the question every side is really arguing about.
Russell Brand has spent the past two years publicly embracing Christianity, getting baptized and even publishing a book on how to become a Christian in seven days. Now, a London jury has unanimously convicted him of rape and sexual assault against four women. It's disturbing to think that while Brand was building a public following around his newfound faith, these women were still waiting for justice.
Why it cuts through A Christian journalist taking the verdict seriously, while much of Brand's new faith audience rushed to defend him.
Russell Brand, convicted of rape, told us who he was. Why didn't Christian leaders listen? My thoughts:
Why it cuts through An evangelical writer asking her own community why it missed the warning signs, instead of blaming the court.
I think it is unfair and unjust for national newspapers to be flooding the zone with more allegations of “sexual misconduct” against Russell Brand. I do not believe any defendant can secure a fair trial – if charges are brought – in this climate. This is not journalism. Are the Times of London now setting up an entire department and devoting their ‘serious journalists’ to investigate the debauched life of Russell Brand over 20 years ago? This as he starts a ten year jail term for rape and sexual assault. How much more of this are they sitting on? This is not serious journalism. In …
Why it cuts through A conservative barrister who accepts the conviction but warns that the coverage since could make any future trial unfair. A due-process point every side should want to keep.
Background on this fight
Russell Brand was sentenced to 10 years and 6 months on 9 November at Southwark Crown Court. A jury had convicted him of one rape and three sexual assaults against four women between 2004 and 2009. It acquitted him of other counts, so the verdict has to be read count by count.
His defenders call the case a stitch-up and point to the lack of forensic evidence. His critics say his fame protected him for years. Both camps tend to skip the question the jury had to answer.
To convict on the rape, the jury had to be sure the woman did not consent and that Brand knew that or was reckless about it. Brand told the court he had never touched a woman sexually without her consent. The judge rejected that account.
For anyone who thinks the verdict is wrong, the honest argument is about the evidence on a specific count, or about where the law draws the line on consent. Calling the trial a political hit job without engaging that question is not the same thing.
The sentencing remarks and the BBC’s count-by-count overview are linked in the recommended reads. The voices above are the ones that engaged with the question instead of the tribe.
Recommended read
BBC NEWS
Russell Brand sentenced to 10-and-a-half years in prison for rape and sexual assault
Count by count: what Brand was convicted and acquitted of, the judge's sentencing remarks, and why he will serve at least seven years before release on licence.
More reporting
- JUDICIARY OF ENGLAND AND WALES R v Russell Brand: sentencing remarks (PDF)
- BBC NEWS Russell Brand found guilty of rape and sexual assault