Who actually stayed home in the midterms
Democrats see a mandate and some on the right see fraud, but the turnout numbers tell a simpler story both sides can check.
The noise
- DEMOCRATS A clear rejection of Trump and a mandate for the opposition.
- SOME ON THE RIGHT Republican turnout was normal, so the Democratic surge is suspicious.
- OTHER REPUBLICANS Our voters stayed home because Congress did nothing with its power.
Cuts through
The midterms story is basically: Republicans showed up at typical midterms level Democrats showed up at presidential level “2024 coalition” voters (independents/hispanics/etc) were pissed about high prices and mass deportations, and either voted Dem or stayed home
Why it cuts through Reconciles the two stories everyone is fighting over: Republicans turned out normally, Democrats turned out like a presidential year, and swing voters were angry about prices.
DeSantis: This midterm was a rebuke of the president and the congress by Democrats, independents and some Republicans that crossed over. But, a lot of our voters stayed home because they were frustrated with the lack of productivity from Republicans in the House and Senate
Why it cuts through A Republican governor saying out loud that some of his own voters stayed home, instead of claiming fraud or waving it away.
35% of President Trump’s 2024 voters stayed home during the 2026 midterms, while 52% voted Republican and 8% switched to Democrats. Among Trump voters aged 18–29, 16% defected to Democrats, while lower Republican turnout accounted for roughly two-thirds of the overall Democratic swing. Follow: @AFpost
Why it cuts through The post-mortem numbers in one post: 35% of Trump voters sat it out, 8% switched. Both parties will plan around these.
Elon Musk says he regrets spending hundreds of millions of dollars in the 2026 midterms: “I think… I feel- I feel pretty foolish about having spent so much money and, and not seeing much for it.”
Why it cuts through The cycle's biggest donor admits his money bought little. Neither 'billionaires buy elections' nor 'Musk carried the GOP' survives that.
Background on this fight
Democrats took both chambers of Congress on 3 November, flipping nine Senate seats. Turnout hit 49% of eligible voters, the second-highest midterm since 1914.
The fight since has been about what that means. Many Democrats read it as a rejection of Trump. Some on the right say Republican turnout was normal, so the Democratic surge must be suspicious. Other Republicans, including Ron DeSantis, say their own voters stayed home because Congress did nothing with its majority.
The post-election polling settles a lot of it. J.L. Partners found 35% of Trump’s 2024 voters did not vote this time and 8% switched to Democrats, with turnout explaining about two-thirds of the swing. Young and Latino voters turned out at near-presidential levels. Cost of living was the top issue in every group, and half of Democratic voters said their vote was against Trump rather than for the party’s platform.
Stateline’s analysis walks through the state-level turnout data and what it says about who showed up and who did not.
Recommended read
STATELINE
Young, diverse voters showed up for midterms as older, Trump voters stayed home
Two analysts' state-level turnout data: around 75% of Democratic gains came from a turnout gap, Texas was the exception, and young voters facing high costs drove the surge.
More reporting